The Lucid Post

Psychology, emotional intelligence, and the patterns that shape who we are.

Self-Worth

She is 64 and just realized she has never once used the good china - not for the anniversary dinners when forty years together surely deserved the formal plates, not for her daughter's engagement, not for the Christmas when the whole family traveled from three states to sit at her table - because a girl who reached for the top shelf and was told 'those are not for every day' spent fifty years waiting for the day that was special enough, and the sixty-four-year-old who eats on stoneware while her wedding china sits above her head still wrapped in tissue paper is not saving it for a special occasion but still waiting for permission to enjoy the things she already owns

By Julia Vance •
Warm sunlight streams into a dining room setting

The Cabinet Above the Refrigerator

I was standing in my kitchen last Tuesday, reheating leftover soup in a bowl I bought at Target eleven years ago, when I looked up and saw the cabinet.

Not just saw it. Really looked at it for the first time in years. The cabinet above the refrigerator - the one you need a step stool to reach, the one that has not been opened since the last time we moved, which was 2014. Inside that cabinet, wrapped in the same tissue paper it arrived in forty-one years ago, is a complete twelve-piece set of Lenox Autumn china. Gold rim. Delicate wheat pattern around the border. My wedding china. The plates I registered for at twenty-three because my mother told me every woman needs a set of good china.

I have never eaten a single meal off those plates.

Not one. Not the Thanksgiving when I cooked for sixteen people and borrowed folding chairs from the church. Not the anniversary dinner when my husband surprised me with flowers and I made his mother’s roast and we ate it on the same scratched stoneware we use every Tuesday. Not the night my daughter called to say she was engaged and we opened a bottle of champagne and I reached for the glasses - not the crystal, the everyday ones - because the crystal was also in a cabinet I do not open.

Forty-one years of meals. Forty-one years of occasions that were apparently never quite special enough for the plates that were bought specifically to mark special occasions.

And standing there with my Target bowl and my reheated soup, I finally asked myself the question I have been avoiding since 1985: what exactly was I saving them for?

The Lesson That Came With the Plates

The china was never really about china.

It was about a rule I learned so early and so completely that I mistook it for a personality trait. The rule was this: beautiful things are not for using. Beautiful things are for having. They are for knowing they are there, for showing guests the cabinet where they live, for telling your daughter someday that she will inherit them. But they are not for Tuesday. They are not for soup.

I learned this from my mother, who learned it from hers. My grandmother had a parlor that no one was allowed to sit in. The furniture was covered in plastic. The curtains were drawn so the upholstery would not fade. There was a candy dish on the coffee table that had held the same ribbon candy since approximately 1971. That room existed to prove that my grandmother owned something worth protecting. It did not exist to be enjoyed.

My mother’s version was subtler but just as absolute. She had good towels in the bathroom that no one was permitted to use. She had a living room sofa with pillows arranged so precisely that sitting on it felt like trespassing. She had a dress in her closet - navy blue, beautiful cut, still had the tags on it when she died - that she was saving for an occasion that never arrived.

A 2017 study published in the Journal of Consumer Psychology found that people who grow up in environments of scarcity - not necessarily poverty, but emotional or material unpredictability - develop what researchers call “conservation bias.” They systematically overestimate the future value of possessions and underestimate the value of present enjoyment. They save things not because they are being careful but because some part of their nervous system believes that using something beautiful is the same as losing it.

I read that study and felt my throat close.

The Inventory of Things I Have Never Touched

Once I started looking, I could not stop counting.

The china was just the beginning. There was the silk scarf my husband brought back from a business trip to Italy in 2003. Still in its box. Still in the drawer. I have worn it exactly zero times because I have never found an outfit worthy of it, which is another way of saying I have never found a version of myself worthy of it.

There was the bottle of perfume my daughter gave me for my sixtieth birthday. The expensive kind, the one I mentioned once in passing and she remembered for three years. I spray it sometimes when I am alone in the house. I have never worn it out. It is almost full, and it is four years old, and perfume expires, and I am watching it expire.

There was the journal - leather-bound, beautiful - that a friend gave me when I retired. “For all the things you finally have time to write down,” the card said. The journal is on my nightstand. It is empty. I have been waiting to have a thought important enough to deserve the first page.

There is a pattern here, and I suspect you recognize it.

You have a version of the good china in your own life. Maybe it is literal - maybe you have plates you do not use, towels you do not unfold, candles you do not light. Or maybe it is something less tangible. Maybe it is the vacation you keep postponing because the timing is never quite right. Maybe it is the book you want to write but will not start because you are waiting to be ready. Maybe it is the words you want to say to someone you love but keep holding in reserve, as if there is a limit on how many times you are allowed to say them.

The mechanism is the same. You are saving the best parts of your life for a version of your life that keeps not arriving.

The Mathematics of Deferred Joy

Here is what I wish someone had told me at twenty-three when I was scanning that Lenox pattern into the wedding registry: there is no special occasion coming.

I do not mean that nothing good will happen. I mean that the idea of a future moment so extraordinary that it justifies using the good plates is a fiction. It is a story we tell ourselves to make the saving feel purposeful instead of what it actually is, which is fear.

The fear goes like this: if I use the beautiful thing and it breaks, I will have nothing. If I wear the scarf and stain it, the magic is gone. If I write in the journal and the words are ordinary, the pages are ruined. If I use the china and someone chips a plate, forty-one years of careful preservation will have been for nothing.

But forty-one years of careful preservation were already for nothing. That is the part no one says out loud.

Brene Brown writes about this - the way we armor ourselves against joy because vulnerability feels too expensive. She calls it “foreboding joy,” the practice of rehearsing tragedy in moments of happiness. I think the good china is a physical manifestation of that. Every time I chose the stoneware over the Lenox, I was protecting myself from the possibility that something beautiful could be damaged by the act of being lived in.

And the cost of that protection is that I have spent forty-one years eating soup out of a bowl I do not love while the bowls I love collect dust three feet above my head.

What My Mother Never Said

My mother died in 2019. When we cleaned out her house, we found the navy dress still in the closet. Tags still on. We found seventeen sets of guest towels in a linen closet that had not been opened in years. We found a bottle of Chanel No. 5 that had turned to something closer to vinegar, still in its box, on her dresser.

I stood in her bedroom holding that bottle and I cried. Not because she was gone - I had already done that crying - but because she had denied herself the pleasure of wearing a perfume she loved for so long that the perfume itself had given up waiting.

A 2021 study in Frontiers in Psychology examined what researchers called “experiential avoidance” in older women - the tendency to postpone pleasurable experiences in favor of maintaining readiness for future needs. The study found that women over sixty were significantly more likely than men of the same age to report owning items they considered “too nice” for regular use. The researchers connected this to gendered socialization around self-sacrifice - the deeply internalized belief that a woman’s resources, including her own pleasure, should be held in reserve for others.

My mother never said “you are not worth the good plates.” She did not have to. She said it with the plastic on the sofa. She said it with the towels no one could touch. She said it with forty years of eating dinner on the same chipped dishes while the good ones waited above her, pristine and pointless.

And I heard her. I heard her so clearly that I repeated the lesson without ever being asked to.

The Evening I Opened the Cabinet

Three weeks ago, on a Wednesday that was not special by any measurable standard, I pulled the step stool over to the refrigerator and I climbed up and I opened that cabinet for the first time in ten years.

The tissue paper had yellowed. I unwrapped one plate. Then another. The gold rim was perfect. The wheat pattern was exactly as delicate as I remembered from the afternoon I first held one up in the department store, newly engaged, imagining the dinners I would serve on these plates, the holidays, the celebrations, the life.

I washed two plates and two bowls by hand. I set them on the counter. And then I reheated the same soup from the same pot and I ate it sitting at my kitchen table on a Tuesday evening in November, alone, on my wedding china.

Nothing extraordinary happened. The soup tasted the same. The plate did not transform the evening into something cinematic. But when I put the plate in the dishwasher afterward - the dishwasher, where it had never once been - I felt something I was not expecting. It was not joy. It was something quieter than that.

It was the feeling of using my own things in my own house as if I had the right to.

If you have a cabinet you do not open, a scarf you do not wear, a candle you do not light, a journal you do not write in, a dress that is waiting for the perfect evening, I want to tell you something that took me sixty-four years to understand.

The special occasion is not coming. It was never coming. The special occasion was supposed to be your life - your ordinary, unremarkable, soup-on-a-Tuesday life. And every dinner you eat on the everyday plates while the good ones gather dust above your head is another evening you chose preservation over presence.

You are allowed to use the beautiful things. You are allowed to use them on a Wednesday. You are allowed to use them alone. You are allowed to use them even though no one is watching and no one will take a photograph and no one will say this evening was worth the plates.

The plates were always worth the evening. You just spent fifty years waiting for someone to tell you that the evening was worth the plates.

No one is coming to tell you. You have to open the cabinet yourself.

Written by

Julia Vance

Mental health and resilience writer

Julia Vance is a writer who spent fifteen years in community mental health before turning to long-form writing about emotional resilience, self-worth, and the psychology of everyday life. She lives in Denver, Colorado.

You might also like