The Lucid Post

Psychology, emotional intelligence, and the patterns that shape who we are.

Relationships

She is 61 and just realized she has never once hung up the phone without saying 'I love you' - not because she always feels it in that moment but because a girl whose grandmother died on a Tuesday between one phone call and the next learned that every conversation might be the last one, and she has spent thirty years making sure the final word is never something ordinary

By Julia Vance •
woman in white scoop neck shirt wearing black framed eyeglasses

I was on hold with my dentist’s office last Thursday - confirming an appointment, nothing more - and when the receptionist said “Alright, you’re all set for the ninth,” I opened my mouth and almost said it.

I love you.

I caught myself. Laughed a little. But something about the near-miss stayed with me for the rest of the afternoon, the way a word sits on your tongue after you swallow it back. Because I realized I have been doing this my entire adult life. Every phone call. Every single one. With my husband, my children, my sister, my friends, my neighbor who calls to ask if I can grab her mail. I say it. I always say it. And I have never once questioned why until I almost said it to a woman named Brenda at a dental office in suburban Ohio.

I am sixty-one years old. And I just understood something about myself that has been running underneath every conversation I have had for the last thirty years.

A Monday Phone Call About Cornbread

My grandmother was the kind of woman who called to tell you things that didn’t need telling. She’d phone on a Monday afternoon to say the tomatoes were coming in early this year, or that she’d seen a cardinal on the fence post, or that she was trying a new cornbread recipe with a little honey stirred in and did I think that was cheating.

I was fourteen. I did not think much about cornbread.

That last Monday call - I remember it with a clarity that should have faded by now but hasn’t - she told me about the cornbread, asked about school, and then said she needed to run because she was going to walk to the store. She needed milk. I said okay. She said she’d talk to me later.

That was it. She’d talk to me later.

By Tuesday evening, she was gone. A stroke, they said. Quick and quiet and completely without warning. She had been standing in her kitchen that morning, alive and ordinary, and then she simply wasn’t.

I did not get to say goodbye. But what haunts me - what has haunted me for forty-seven years - is not the absence of a goodbye. It’s the presence of something ordinary in its place. The last thing I said to my grandmother was something about picking up milk. I might have said “okay” or “sounds good.” I honestly can’t remember which. But I know what I didn’t say.

I didn’t say I love you.

Not because I didn’t feel it. Because it wasn’t part of the script. We just didn’t end calls that way. People didn’t, not every time, not like breathing. You saved it for birthdays and holidays and the long pauses before hanging up at the airport.

And then she was gone, and the last word between us was something about dairy.

The Ritual That Built Itself

I don’t remember making a conscious decision. There was no moment where I sat down and said, “From now on, I will end every phone call with I love you.” It was more like something that grew over the silence she left behind.

At first it was just family. My mother, my father, my sister. The people whose loss I could now imagine with terrible specificity. I started saying it every time, and they said it back, and nobody questioned it because we were all grieving and love was the only word that felt big enough to hold what we were carrying.

Then it expanded. Close friends. Then not-so-close friends. Then the neighbor, the colleague, the old roommate who calls once a year on my birthday.

A 2016 study published in the journal Death Studies found that people who experience sudden, unexpected loss often develop what researchers call “anticipatory rituals” - repetitive behaviors designed to pre-emptively close the emotional loops that death left open. The rituals aren’t about the present moment. They’re about the past one. The one that ended wrong.

That’s what I built without knowing it. A closing bracket. A seal pressed into the wax at the end of every letter, even the short ones, even the ones that are just about picking up milk or confirming a dental appointment.

I love you became my way of saying: this conversation is complete. If this is the last one, it ended right.

”You Say It Even When You’re Angry With Me”

My husband noticed before I did. We’d been married about eight years when he said it one night after a fight - not a big one, just the low-grade irritation that builds up when two people share a bathroom and a mortgage and a different opinion about how to load a dishwasher.

I was furious with him. Genuinely, properly angry. And as I turned to leave the room, phone in hand because I’d been talking to my sister when the argument started, I said it to him over my shoulder. “Love you.”

He stopped me. “You do that every time,” he said. “Even when you’re mad at me. Even when you clearly don’t want to be in the same room as me. You still say it.”

I didn’t have an answer. I just shrugged and said, “Because I do.”

But the truth was more specific than that. The truth was: because anger is temporary, but death is not. Because I have lived inside the space between one phone call and the next, and I know what it’s like when that space becomes permanent. I would rather you hear something redundant than something insufficient. I would rather say it when I don’t feel it than risk a world where I never get the chance to feel it again.

Dennis Klass, the psychologist who developed continuing bonds theory, argued that we don’t “get over” grief by severing our connection to the person we lost. We get through it by finding new ways to maintain the relationship. The bond doesn’t end. It transforms. We carry the dead forward in rituals and habits and small devotions that might look irrational to anyone who hasn’t lost someone between a Monday and a Tuesday.

My husband understood, eventually. Not because I explained it well but because he watched me do it for twenty more years and saw that it never wavered. Not when I was tired. Not when I was distracted. Not when I was so angry my hands were shaking. The words came out the same every time, steady as a heartbeat.

Because they were never about how I felt in the moment. They were about what I knew could happen in the next one.

The Daughter Who Inherited a Ritual She Doesn’t Know the Origin Of

My daughter is thirty-three. She ends every phone call with “love you.” Every one. She says it to me, to her father, to her friends, to her brother, to the babysitter she’s close with. She says it the way other people say “bye” - automatically, unconsciously, like punctuation.

She has never lost anyone suddenly. She has never stood in a kitchen and learned that someone she spoke to yesterday is gone today. She doesn’t know why she does it.

But I do.

Research published in Frontiers in Psychology in 2021 found that grief-driven behavioral patterns frequently transmit across generations, even when the original loss is never explicitly discussed. Children absorb the emotional rhythms of their parents - not the content but the cadence. They learn not what to fear but how to protect against it. My daughter doesn’t fear sudden loss the way I do. But she inherited my protection against it, the way you inherit an accent or a preference for a certain kind of music.

She says “love you” because I always said it. And I always said it because my grandmother died on a Tuesday and the last word I offered her was ordinary.

There’s something both beautiful and heartbreaking about that. My daughter carries a ritual born from grief, but she carries it without the grief. It’s just how she ends a phone call. It’s just what you do. And maybe that’s the best possible outcome - that the wound heals but the wisdom stays, passed down like a recipe, like a cornbread with a little honey stirred in.

The Weight of Ordinary Words

I think about ordinary words more than most people do. I think about the last thing you say before you walk out the door in the morning, and whether it matters, and whether it would matter more if you knew.

Here’s what I’ve learned in sixty-one years of paying attention to endings: you never know which conversation is the last one. You think you do. You think the big ones announce themselves - the hospital calls, the late-night confessions, the long drives home from funerals. But the last conversation is almost always ordinary. It’s about cornbread. It’s about picking up milk. It’s about whether Tuesday works for the appointment.

A 2019 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people consistently underestimate the emotional impact of brief, casual expressions of affection. A quick “I love you” at the end of a routine phone call registered as deeply meaningful to the recipient, even when the speaker considered it throwaway. We think love only counts when it’s dramatic. But the research says otherwise. The small, repeated, almost-automatic expressions of love are the ones people remember. The ones they reach for when they’re trying to reconstruct what a person meant to them.

I have said “I love you” thousands of times when I didn’t particularly feel it. When I was preoccupied. When I was annoyed. When I was running late and just wanted to hang up. And I don’t regret a single one.

Because those words were never about the moment I was in. They were about the moment I was afraid of. The one where the phone rings and the person on the other end tells you something has changed, and you have to live inside every conversation you’ve ever had with that person, replaying the last one, checking the last word, wondering if it was enough.

Mine will always be enough. I made sure of it.

Not Anxiety - A Promise

People might read this and think I’m anxious. That I live in fear of death, that I can’t relax into an ordinary Tuesday without bracing for loss. And I understand why it might look that way from the outside.

But it doesn’t feel like anxiety from the inside. It feels like a promise.

When I was fourteen, standing in my mother’s kitchen, learning that my grandmother was gone, I made a decision. I didn’t make it consciously. I didn’t write it down. But something in me shifted, the way a bone sets after a break - not perfectly, not without a ridge you can feel if you press hard enough, but solidly. Permanently.

The decision was this: no conversation would ever end the way that last one did. Not if I could help it.

And I have kept that promise for forty-seven years. Through marriages and arguments and busy mornings and idle afternoons and calls with the dentist and calls with my daughter and calls where I was laughing and calls where I was crying and calls where I felt nothing at all except the low hum of another day passing.

I love you. Every time. Without exception.

My grandmother never got to hear it from me one last time. But everyone else will. That’s not fear talking. That’s a fourteen-year-old girl who learned something about the fragility of ordinary moments and decided to make every ending sacred, even the small ones. Especially the small ones.

If you do this too - if you’re the person who can’t hang up without saying it, who whispers it even when you’re mad, who almost says it to strangers - I want you to know something.

You’re not anxious. You’re not clingy. You’re not broken.

You’re someone who understands that love is not a feeling you save for special occasions. It’s a practice. A daily one. A word you place at the end of every conversation like a period at the end of a sentence, because you know that some sentences end mid-thought, and you want to make sure yours never does.

That fourteen-year-old girl inside you kept her word. And that is one of the most faithful things a person can do.

Written by

Julia Vance

Mental health and resilience writer

Julia Vance is a writer who spent fifteen years in community mental health before turning to long-form writing about emotional resilience, self-worth, and the psychology of everyday life. She lives in Denver, Colorado.

You might also like