The Lucid Post

Psychology, emotional intelligence, and the patterns that shape who we are.

Generational Identity

There is a particular kind of man who has never once said 'I love you' to his father - who stands in the driveway after every holiday visit and shakes the old man's hand instead, who has written it in birthday cards but crossed it out and written 'proud of you' because that felt safer, who carries the words in his throat every time the phone call is ending but says 'alright, talk soon' instead - but says it to his own children every single night, three words at bedtime like a prayer he is teaching them that no one ever taught him, because the boy who grew up in a house where love was proven in snow tires installed before the first frost and a father who drove four hours to fix a leaking faucet but never once named the thing that made him drive decided to build a door his children could walk through even knowing he would spend his whole life standing on the other side of it

By Marcus Reid •
silhouette of 2 children standing on beach during sunset

My father has never told me he loves me. I am forty-six years old. I have a mortgage, a bad knee, two kids who think I’m embarrassing, and a certainty as solid as anything I own that my father loves me more than he has ever loved anything in his life. He has just never said it.

Not once. Not when I graduated. Not when I got married. Not when I called him from the hospital parking lot, shaking, to tell him his first grandchild had been born and was healthy and had his hands.

What he said was: “Good. That’s good. You did good.”

And I stood in that parking lot and cried, not because the words were wrong but because they were the most my father has ever been able to give, and I could hear in the crack of his voice that there was a whole ocean behind them trying to get through a keyhole.

I tell my kids I love them every night. Every single night. I say it at bedtime. I say it when they leave for school. I say it when they do something small and kind and don’t realize anyone noticed. I say it when they mess up. I say it when there’s no reason to say it at all, just because the house is quiet and they’re sitting there and the words are right there in my mouth and I have made a decision - the most deliberate decision of my adult life - that those words will never go unsaid in my house.

That decision did not come from a book. It came from the driveway.

The driveway

Every man who grew up the way I did knows about the driveway. The driveway is where the visit ends. The driveway is where you have been sitting at your father’s kitchen table for three hours, talking about the car and the roof and whether the neighbor finally took down that dead tree, and now it’s time to go and you’re standing by your car and there’s a moment - a physical, actual moment you can feel in your chest like a held breath - where the words are right there.

I love you, Dad.

Four syllables. Children say them. Toddlers say them with cereal in their mouths. But standing in that driveway, facing a man who shook your hand when you were twelve and hasn’t hugged you since your mother’s funeral, those four syllables are the hardest sentence in the English language.

So you shake his hand. You do the thing where you grip and lean in slightly and slap his shoulder with the other hand, which is the closest physical gesture your family has ever developed for what normal people just call a hug. And you drive away. And somewhere around the interstate the words dissolve, and you tell yourself next time, knowing that you told yourself next time last time, and the time before that, and the time before that.

A 2015 study published in the Journal of Family Communication found that fathers who grew up in homes with low verbal affection were 74 percent less likely to verbally express love to their own fathers, even when they reported high levels of felt affection. The researchers called it “expressive inertia” - the gap between what a person feels and what the relational template they inherited allows them to say. They feel the love. They cannot find the door.

I am one of those men. I have always been one of those men. And the thing I need you to understand is that this is not a complaint about my father.

The man who showed up

My father is not a villain in this story. My father is the man who drove across three counties in an ice storm to bring me a space heater the winter my apartment lost heat. My father is the man who didn’t say a word when I changed my major for the third time but quietly kept paying tuition. My father is the man who, when my marriage was falling apart and I couldn’t tell anyone, somehow knew to call every Sunday at six and talk about absolutely nothing for forty-five minutes, which was his way of sitting next to me without asking me to explain.

His love was never absent. It was structural. It held things up. It was the kind of love you don’t notice until you lean on it and find that it’s been load-bearing this entire time.

He learned that from his father, who learned it from his. Men of a certain generation - men born into houses where feelings were liabilities and vulnerability was a door you kept locked because the draft would kill you - built their love out of what they had: reliability, presence, labor, silence. They showed up. They fixed things. They went to work sick. They didn’t talk about it.

Psychologist Terry Real, in his work on generational masculinity, describes what he calls the “normal male trauma” of emotional disconnection - not a dramatic wound but a quiet, inherited narrowing of what men are permitted to express. Each generation passes down not cruelty but constriction. The channel through which love can flow gets narrower and narrower until a man can feel everything and say almost nothing, and the people who love him have to learn to read actions instead of words.

My father is fluent in that language. He speaks it beautifully. I just decided my children would be bilingual.

The decision

I don’t remember making it formally. There was no moment where I sat down and thought: I will be the man who says it out loud. It was more like a slow accumulation.

The first time was in the hospital. My daughter was maybe three hours old and already had a grip on my index finger that I would have followed anywhere. I looked at her face and said it. Just said it. “I love you.” And the words came out so easily that I almost laughed, because I had spent my whole life watching those same words get stuck in my father’s throat and here they were, falling out of me like breathing.

I said it again the next day. And the next. And somewhere in that first week it became a practice, and then a habit, and then a vow I never consciously made but have never once broken.

My son was born four years later, and by then the practice was set. I love you at bedtime. I love you at drop-off. I love you at the end of phone calls. I love you when you’ve done nothing to earn it, which is the whole point, which is what I needed someone to teach me when I was their age - that the words are not a reward. They are a weather report. They describe what is always true regardless of behavior.

A 2021 study in Developmental Psychology tracked the emotional expression patterns of over 1,200 fathers across two generations and found that men who consciously adopted more verbally expressive parenting styles than their own fathers often described the shift not as rebellion but as completion - as finishing something their fathers had started but lacked the tools to articulate. The researchers noted that these men rarely criticized their own fathers. They spoke of them with deep tenderness. They understood, with an almost painful clarity, that the silence was not absence but limitation.

That is exactly right. I am not correcting my father. I am finishing his sentence.

The weight of the bridge

There is a cost to being the transitional generation, and I want to name it because I don’t think it gets named.

My children will grow up in a house where love is spoken. They will absorb it the way children absorb everything - invisibly, completely, without knowing it’s remarkable. They will say “I love you” to their own children someday and it will feel as natural as breathing because it has always been the air in their house. They will not know what it cost.

They will not know that their father practiced saying it in the mirror before they were born. They will not know about the driveway. They will not know that the man who says it to them every night still cannot say it to his own father, that there is a phone call every Sunday where the words line up like soldiers and never make it past the gate.

They will walk across the bridge I built and they will not see me standing on the other side of it, watching them go.

And that is exactly how it should be. That is the whole point of a bridge. You don’t build it so people will admire the engineering. You build it so people can cross. The best bridges are the ones nobody thinks about because they’re too busy getting to the other side.

But sometimes, on a Sunday evening after the phone call, after I’ve said “alright, talk soon” one more time instead of what I mean, I sit in the car for a minute. And I feel the weight of being the man in the middle. The man who receives love in one language and delivers it in another. The man who translates between a generation that couldn’t say it and a generation that will never understand why it was hard.

The thing he already knows

Last Thanksgiving, I stood in my father’s driveway. Same driveway. Same moment. Same held breath. My kids were already in the car, arguing about something. My wife was checking her phone. And my father was standing there in his jacket, hands in his pockets, looking at me the way he always does at the end of a visit - like he’s trying to memorize something.

I shook his hand. I did the lean-in, the shoulder pat. And then I said it.

I don’t know why that time was different. Maybe it was the way the light was hitting his face. Maybe it was that my son had hugged him goodbye without hesitation, had thrown his arms around the old man’s waist and said “love you, grandpa” the way he says everything - easily, freely, like the words had no weight at all - and I saw something cross my father’s face that I had never seen before.

“Love you, Dad.”

It came out quiet. Almost a whisper. And my father didn’t say it back. He just nodded. And squeezed my hand harder. And turned away a little too quickly, the way men of his generation turn away when they need a moment.

He knew. He has always known. The driveway was never about information. It was about permission.

And my son, watching from the backseat, probably thought nothing of it. Just his dad saying goodbye.

Which is exactly how it’s supposed to work. The bridge holds because the man in the middle carries the weight where no one can see it. And his children walk across, light and free, into a world where love doesn’t get stuck in anyone’s throat.

That is the inheritance I am building. Not money. Not property. The ability to say the truest thing out loud.

My father built the foundation. He just didn’t have the words for the rest.

I do. And every night at bedtime, I use them.

Written by

Marcus Reid

Relationships and psychology writer

Marcus Reid is a writer focused on relationships, masculinity, and the emotional patterns men are rarely given language for. He spent years working in counseling before shifting to writing about the things people carry but never say out loud. He lives in Chicago.

You might also like